11 September 2025
An Islamabad sessions court has struck down a lower court’s order that directed YouTube to block 27 channels accused of spreading “fake, misleading and derogatory content” against state institutions. The ruling provided temporary relief to 11 petitioners
In July, a judicial magistrate had ordered the blocking of 27 YouTube channels, alleging they were disseminating false and derogatory material targeting the government and armed forces.
The channels were run by political commentators, journalists, influencers, and several overseas-based individuals.
Court Decision
Additional District and Sessions Judge (ADSJ) Mohammad Afzal Majoka presided over the appeals and questioned the legal grounds for shutting down entire channels.
The judge expressed displeasure with the prosecutor from the National Cyber Crimes Investigation Agency, raising concerns over the misuse of authority.
The court accepted petitions from 11 channel owners, overturning the lower court’s order in their cases, while hinting that those absent in hearings could lose their appeals.
Implications
The decision is a significant marker in the ongoing debate on freedom of expression and regulatory control over digital platforms in Pakistan.
It highlights the judiciary’s role in scrutinizing administrative overreach when it comes to censorship.
While some petitioners gained relief, the broader question of online content regulation remains unsettled.
